skip to main content skip to footer


Five stars. Fantastic brisket, pulled pork and other meats. Great brussel sprouts. The fried pickles were a great choice. Decent beer menu. Friendly, knowledgeable staff. Clean and inviting location. Well worth a trip. I'll be going back....
John DeWitt via - Sep 22, 2020
Brisket was amazing! Nice atmosphere!
Paul Seugling via - Sep 21, 2020
Great food and service. Clean and open air Def get the bacon burnt ends!
Green Team 07016 via - Sep 17, 2020
The place serves large dishes and for convenient prices. very welcoming staff members. Great work.
Hiram Waller via - Sep 16, 2020
Amazing food and ambiance. Even the cornbread is mouthwatering! Will definitely be back with friends ... read more
Andrew Dina via - Sep 13, 2020
good atmosphere friendly bartenders and good briscuit ... read more
roger gross via - Sep 12, 2020
We were waiting for this place to open when we finally were able to get there they had just opened for outside dinning we waited about 30 min to be seated while having a drink the bartender acaully ended charging my card 3 times 2 times was a mistake she told me it will show up pending which it was acaully finalized I just was able t ... read more
joe bali via - Sep 9, 2020
I love the cheesy grits, brisket, ribs, and pecan pie!
Marcus Montgomery via - Sep 9, 2020
We had lunch here and the food was very good. The drinks were also good. Overall great time.
Tammy Robles via - Sep 7, 2020
Great BBQ!! You must give this place a try ... read more
John Ferrito via - Sep 7, 2020
So good! One of the best ribs i had ! Service so good and the ambiance is great. We love it. Definitely a place to come back not once, many times!
Ana Valiente via - Sep 7, 2020
This place is a win...Inside decor is beautiful..Food was great..Tonight even had a band playing grown folks music..πŸ‘ Just an enjoyable night at reasonable price..πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘πŸ‘ ... read more
Howard Smith via - Sep 6, 2020
Food is amazing great service awesome corn bread ... read more
Jeff Vanderbilt via - Sep 6, 2020
The food the place amazing. Hands down these Brothers are the best.
Mark Carter via - Sep 6, 2020
Absolutely gorgeous dining room and full bar. Friendly helpful staff. Outside dining available. Good quality food including a large variety of side dishes at a reasonable price.
Bruce Snider via - Sep 4, 2020
I would have never thought that the best bbq I have ever had would be in NJ and I have traveled all over the United States. Unbelievable, this place is the real deal. Food and service were excellent. Welcome to the area! It's nice to see that somebody is doing bbq right around here, finally! Will be back for sure.
Steven L via - Aug 29, 2020
Great food great service, it's nice to see a REAL BBQ restaurant in the area. Keep up the good work. see ya soon.
Glen Lombardi via - Aug 29, 2020
Excellent food and service! Ordered 1/2 rack of St. Louis ribs, mac & cheese and beans plus cornbread that comes with the meal - all delicious. Look forward to returning very soon.
D.C. Walker via - Aug 24, 2020
I order the 2 combo (chicken and st.louis ribs). Three sides yams, Mac and cheese and baked beans. ( an extra side is 5.50 FYI) The food was great expect the Mac and cheese it was okay. The service was great in the beginning but towards the end our waiter JIll rush out the restaurant. She literally pick up the check with the tip in i ... read more
Shamika Edwards via - Aug 24, 2020
Great Food, Cool Vibe, Cute Buss Boys! I can't Wait until the inside opens up.
Diana Kadan via - Aug 24, 2020
So happy this place opened up the food is delicious and cooked perfectly. Our waitress Nicolette was attentive and personable, she recommended and suggested a few items off the menu which were amazing we were extremely pleased we will be back!
Nancy K. via - Aug 24, 2020
Excellent BBQ. The 'Eat Like A King' platter was more than enough for 4 adults. All of the meats (chicken, baby back ribs, pulled pork, and brisket) were juicy, tender, and had a beautiful smoke ring. Coming from Texas where BBQ is judged like a sport with a Michelin tongue, Brotherhood definitely scores well in taste, friendliness, ... read more
James Garvin via - Aug 22, 2020
I lived down south so I know great BBQ, and this place is spot on. So happy I'm local to it. Looking for coupons as it is a bit pricy but its amazing ... read more
Luke DeMercurio via - Aug 22, 2020
I was really looking forward to trying this restaurant and decided on the brisket sandwich which was absolutely delicious. The meat and bread were of high quality. The french fries and Brussels sprouts were also flavorful. The service was seamless and the order was accurate. I will be trying more options on the menu and if you are lo ... read more
Noah Field via - Aug 21, 2020
Food was so fricking good. The Mac and cheese had me actin up. (For old people reading this that’s a good thing) i dont kno who was cleaning the tables and all but they were crystal clear 😩. And the hostess really got us to our table quick and goodly. 10/10 recommend ... read more
John Rodriguez via - Aug 18, 2020
Nice outdoor setup. Looking forward to seeing the inside. Staff was super friendly. They were out of iced tea and soda which was odd. They had just opened when we arrived. Food was pretty good. Sides better than the mains. Complementary cornbread was delicious. Prices a bit steep. Will definitely go back though!
Brian Zagen via - Aug 14, 2020
Ate here with a few friends the other day and it was absolutely delicious! Their bbq sauce is the best I’ve had in a long time. Looking to come in with husband for dinner. So glad a great bbq place opened up near us.
Amanda Marx via - Aug 14, 2020
Everything was fantastic from the cornbread to the ribs. The service was also excellent despite being outside in a tent. I highly recommend Brothers!
Christopher Tausch via - Aug 13, 2020
Food is just amazing. I never tasted cornbread like that. Everything was off the charts.
Samuel Lazzaro via - Aug 12, 2020
What an experience! The one thing I feel what has been missing in this area (no offense to other places) is a good southern style bbq/smokehouse and brothers smokehouse is the place the bo shrimp appetizer was very good love the fact they use house made sauces ranch bleu cheese etc the pulled pork brisket best myself and my wife have ... read more
rdfjr1118 Jr via - Aug 12, 2020
Fantastic food and a great outdoor atmosphere so far. My family enjoyed a late lunch on opening day before the evening dinner rush. We'll definitely be going back.
Peter DePasquale via - Aug 10, 2020
Jose Rodriguez via - Aug 7, 2020
By FAR THE BEST BBQ IN THE TRI STATE AREA !! original joint opened about a hour north in new Windsor, NY .. baby back ribs are succulent , brisket is tender and juicy , smoked chicken will leave you absolutely speechless 😢.. the brothers are all gentlemen and very welcoming to all their guests ! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED TO EVERYONE!
Mikey MOMO via - Jul 27, 2020
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire